Sunday, March 20, 2011

"It's everybody so it's nobody"

Dr. Krantzberg's presentation: Great Lakes Great Responsibility, touched upon major water quality and governance issues that are not very familiar to the larger public, although the problem resides right in our Canadian backyard. To think that the mechanisms set to protect the Great Lakes are in reality outdated and not adequately coordinated between Canada and the US, is a reason for major concern. 

Despite the myth of abundance, reality remains that only 1% of the Great Lakes are renewable through rainfall. In the documentary Waterlife, it is claimed the Great Lakes are the last remaining large source of fresh water in the world. Given this claim, and also given the old and new problems that have emerged (i.e eutrophication, sewer overflow, toxic chemicals, invasive species, etc.), the recent revision of GLWQA (Great Lakes Water Quality Agreement- 1972) should address the bi-national governance deficit that has stalled the adoption of a preventative approach. This is critical in order to foresee problems before they arise rather than continue to employ the traditional reactionary attitude that has led us to where we are today in terms of the Great Lakes' deplorable conditions. 

When questions such as "Who is responsible for what?" are posed, the general response is "it's everyone's responsibility" and with this broad-based sense of responsibility, no one feels obligated to assume the role of the culpable. This ambiguity in turn leads to inertia in governance and points to a serious gap in policies and problem-solving mechanisms. 


Dr. Krantzberg emphasized the need for a strong bi-national agreement that can hold both national governments (US and Canada) accountable to an equal amount of dedication of resources and attention for the Great Lakes (as the lakes are divided 50-50). However, as Dr. Krantzberg began to share with us the success of her experience in working with near-shore communities around the lake to restore the conditions of the water and surrounding environment, I became more cognizant of the momentousness of bottom-up initiatives to fill policy gaps and governance inertia. Regardless of the stature of a commitment initiated at higher levels of governance and the promise it holds, the grandeur of such top-down statements can lead to mayhem if a well-coordinated system at every level and area of expertise is not well envisioned and practiced. In the case of nearshore communities around the Lake Victoria Basin in Kenya for example, it seems that self-help initiatives are increasingly becoming the solution to alternative water provision that can reduce pressure from the Lake and also address gaps in policies,  as government and industry actors remain passive. In times of desperation and a threat to livelihood and well-being, a sense of urgency sparks agency at the individual and community level and although it may not be the solution to all the problems, it is the most impactful. It is the bridge between paper agreements and action. 

In brief, concerted efforts need to reside both at the macro governance platform, and more importantly at the involved communities' level. Although it is not fair to shift the burden of responsibility fully onto near-shore communities, their endogenous concern and action can offset the inaction of other actors. In fact, their concern and ownership of the problem will consequently result in placing pressure on policymakers to give greater attention to the cause. I believe that in the revision of GLWQA and its annexes, greater attention and resources must be dedicated to near-shore communities with the goal of raising awareness and working on endogenous solutions. There is no doubt that the given communities, with support from the greater concerned public, experts and governments will take bolder action to protect the Great Lakes and bequeath them to future generations, as challenging a task as that may be. 

Thursday, February 17, 2011

To "C"ommunicate or to "c"ommunicate?

Who would have thought the dynamics of communication between science experts and policy experts needed decoding before it is communicated? During Dr. Bielak's talk, it became evident that experts seem to be insulated within their own fields and accustomed to speaking their own discipline's coded language. Consequently, whenever exchange of information is necessary to "outsiders", it is not communicated in an effective manner, or perhaps the message is not "decoded" appropriately by the receiver.

The process of communication is complex (it consists of a sender who encodes a message that is then transmitted through a medium, and then decoded by the receiver). I found it difficult at the outset to understand the term "knowledge brokering" or even its relevance to this complex process. However, it soon began to make sense that since "big C" (Communication department) takes care of catering to the larger publics, "little c" is needed to attend to communicating to more specific publics such as policy makers, decision makers, and most importantly the interested/attentive public. The quality, depth and breadth of information need to be tailored appropriately to actively engage these important audiences.

This is where it gets interesting. Knowledge brokering is the intermediary process at the level of “little c” that helps to build links by bringing relevant people together to share ideas, assisting them in understanding each other's abilities and needs, and guiding them to sources of knowledge.[1] More importantly, the role of knowledge brokers becomes essential in helping ensure that the right questions are being answered.

Beginning to think about this complex process, particularly in communicating knowledge that is confined within our various disciplines led me to reflect on the dynamics within our multi-disciplinary WWB team. Everytime I write these blogs, I struggle to ensure I am effectively communicating the intended message with enough clarity for all my colleagues (who I am sure agree is not an easy task!). It also became more obvious that a gap exists in communication as soon as we began to test our elevator speeches during the seminar, using terminology that was discipline oriented and not quite comprehensible to out-of-discipline colleagues. Lesson learnt in both cases: know your message and know your audience!

Regardless, with a little tweaking, I am certain we will all have well-polished elevator speeches that effectively communicate the right message to the right audiences (thanks to Dr. Bielak). 

Here is mine - please critique:

“Hello, my name is Dona and I am a graduate student in Globalization Studies and Water Without Borders. My research aims to identify the obstacles embedded within national water policies that prevent rural populations from exercising their rights to access clean water and a healthy living standard. It will also explore policy trends at the international level that steer national water policies in the direction of excluding rural areas. Greater attention to this issue can facilitate achieving the Millenium Development Goals and improving the output of policies in the water sector. I am asking to be granted funding for this project as I am certain the findings will have the potential to be emulated and tested in different settings. I hope I captured your interest and will be glad to provide further details regarding my work.”



[1] Bielak, A.T., A. Campbell, S. Pope, K. Schaefer and L. Shaxson “From Science Communications to Knowledge Brokering: The Shift from Science Push to Policy Pull.” In Cheng, D., M. Claessens, T. Gascoigne, J. Metcalfe, B.Schiele and S. Shi (eds), Communicating Science in Social Contexts: New Models, New Practices. Dordrecht: Springer., 2008:  220.

Thursday, February 3, 2011

Developing capacity with developing policies.

“The only reason we are on track with water MDGs is because we are reaching for the ‘low-hanging fruit’ as the urban and peri-urban populations are easier to reach in terms of provision of water and sanitation. The rural population and the rural poor are more difficult to supply” – Dr. Mayfield

The notion of the “low-hanging fruit” presented by Dr. Mayfield helped confirm the greater relevance of my gradually developing MRP on globalization and its impact on development of water policies. Globalization has certainly helped facilitate increased progress on many fronts for improving water quality, access and attention to urban and peri-urban areas.[1] However, the fruits of globalization as discussed in this seminar were largely targeted at urban areas with easier potential for supply and development, marginalizing a whole section of the population who seem to be always left behind on the bandwagon to “development”- the rural poor.

Rural areas and water provision are the next big challenge because providing money and solutions to rural communities is much more difficult. This under investment coupled with increasing environmental targets eventually lead to the need to privatize the industry in order to generate sufficient additional funds.[2] The problem is that with law reforms pushing for increased private tenure and the predominant poorer status of rural communities, two phenomena are occurring:
  1.  Laws become discriminatory as they increase class division by permitting those with capital to purchase land and water rights, further marginalizing the poor and certain communal traditions.
  2. In many cases the private sector itself marginalizes rural communities given they yield less returns on investment due to predominantly poorer socio-economic conditions and distance from urban centers (where profit exists).
Brooks explains that “national and supranational strategies alone are not enough” anymore to deal with water scarcity and that “experience around the world proves that local management is essential to the sustainable exploitation of scarce water supplies” especially because local management permits a democratizing decentralization of decision and accountability.[3]

With a focus on local management, greater attention should be dedicated to capacity development. The Four Pillars approach developed by UNU-INWEH refers to the interdependency between the public sector, the community and community based organizations, the private sector and academic sector in capacity development. The emphasis is on the "capacity to educate and train, to measure and understand aquatic systems, to legislate and regulate and to provide appropriate, affordable water infrastructure". Perhaps with increased capacity building opportunities offered to individuals in local rural areas, the first step towards bridging the gap of privilege and accessibility is successfully taken. However, how far can this step go if policies implemented from above seem to have the tendency to reverse these progressive developments?


[1] Although some may argue it has also had negative implications with greater interference of international organizations in domestic affairs and a strong push for privatization- with criticism increasingly directed at the World Bank.
[3] Brooks, David B. Water: Local-level Management. Ottawa: International Development Research Centre, 2002, p6.

Wednesday, January 19, 2011

How prepared is the Middle East?

“Are water scarce countries equipped and ready to meet the challenge of a global water crisis?” This was one of the first questions Dr. Thomas posed at us during his presentation.

The relevance of this question struck me given the current headlines making the news about the unstable situation in the Middle East. According to the presentation, the Middle East is considered to be suffering from a physical scarcity of water (vs. economic scarcity of water such as in Africa). Tunisia, Jordan, Egypt, Algeria, Iraq and Lebanon are among the countries currently facing civil or political unrest. Perhaps water is not presently the focal issue for these countries’ governments, however, given their current struggles, will they be well equipped to deal with increasing water shortages? Can there be a link between the rising price of staples and increasing water scarcity?

A wave of violent demonstrations recently took over Algeria and Tunisia as well as Jordan in protest over high prices, unemployment and falling living standards.[1] Jordan consequently announced a $225 million package of cuts in the prices of some types of fuel and of staple products including sugar and rice, and other Arab countries have taken similar steps.[2] This was merely a reactive response to escalating dissent. Although some may argue rising prices in commodities, staples and fuel, is the influence of the recent economic downturn; I speculate they are more linked to faulty or inadequate non-proactive policies. Shortage in water will soon be, if not already, another reason for an environment of political tension and civil unrest in these water scarce countries.  

Desertification was discussed as a major problem in drylands, which in fact cover an area of 41% of the world and are home to over 2 billion people.[3] With increasing desertification, there is less opportunity for local and national self-sufficiency and less crop growth, which in turn leads to food insecurity and causes labour/rural to urban migration and even cases of environmental refugees.

If desertification and the decreasing appeal of the agricultural sector are main causes in labour migration and increasing prices of staples (thus causing civil unrest), then perhaps governments should begin to create forward looking policies that focus on creating jobs through improving the agricultural sector, to improve production efficiency (with higher value crops, fit for water scarce regions as Dr. Thomas mentioned) and to reduce rural to urban migration. Further, policies should also start focusing on reviving traditional mechanisms of water collection in drier regions as these seem to be the most sustainable and environmentally-friendly, and a gateway to maintaining and improving crop growth in certain areas, thus requiring greater labour and reducing migration out of these regions.[4]

Perhaps the link between the current riots in the Middle East and problems of desertification due to global warming and water scarcity is not so obvious at first. It has not been unveiled through mainstream media, nor probed at by journalists. However, addressing issues of employment security alone will not resolve the dilemma, so long as food and water security issues remain marginalized. Unless this link is identified, a root source of instability will only be dormant before it erupts.  Priorities need to be reevaluated.


[1] Holly Pickett. “Tunisia”. The New York Times. Jan. 19, 2011. Accessed Jan 19 2011. <http://topics.nytimes.com/top/news/international/countriesandterritories/tunisia/index.html>.
[2] Suleiman al-Khalidi. “Hundreds protest over high prices in south Jordan”. Reuters Africa. Fri Jan 14, 2011. Accessed Jan 19, 2011. <http://af.reuters.com/article/worldNews/idAFTRE70D3AQ20110114>.
[3] Bigas, H., Adeel, Z., & Shuster, C. (eds) “Seeing traditional technologies in a new light.” 2009. <http://unesdoc.unesco.org/images/0018/001817/181799e.pdf>.
[4] ibid.

Tuesday, January 4, 2011

Legal Framework for Water Regulation in Kenya: Advances and Exclusions

The legal status of all water resources including rainwater has been in most cases that of a property. In certain African countries, water resources belong to the people, public or nation and are simply controlled by the government.[1] In Kenya however, all water resources are the property of the government (under Part II, section 3 of the Water Act, 2002 it was amended to “state” but does not signify a substantial change in the legal status).[2]

The National Water Services Strategy (NWSS) was presented by the Minister for Water and Irrigation in Kenya, in 2007, for the development, management and monitoring of water and sewerage services.[3] This is because the WSS situation had been very poor, whereby according to a 2007 report from the Ministry of Water and Irrigation, only about 57% of households at that time used water from “safe” sources; sustainable access to safe water was about 60% in urban settings and as low as 20% in settlements of the urban poor where half of the urban population lives; sustainable water access in rural areas was about 40%; and sanitation coverage was only about 50%.[4] In addition, vendors in Kenya sell water of “uncontrolled quality” which costs between 5 to 20 times the tariff applied on consumers with metered water connections.[5]  As a consequence, the impacts of poor water service and quality are mainly felt by low income consumers who cannot afford alternate mechanisms of filtering or cleaning water, or paying for metered water that may or may not be running regularly. 

The goals set by this strategy (NWSS) targeted for 2015 include reaching at least 50% of the underserved urban population and 50% of the underserved in rural areas with safe and affordable water by 2015 and sustainable access to all by 2030; increasing access to “safe and improved” basic sanitation facilities particularly for the poor to 77.5% in the urban setting and 72.5% in the rural setting; as well as providing sustainable waterborne sewage collection, treatment and disposal systems to 40% of the urban and 10% of the rural population by 2015.[6] The status of progress achieved under this strategy thus far remains to be investigated.

Upon going through the Water Act amended in 2002, along with the NWSS report, one realizes that a main route the government has taken to achieve these goals is through a focus on decentralization and delegation through public-private partnerships and “undertakerships” where water licenses are issued under the Water Act, Chapter 372 to supply water within an area.[7]

Initially in Kenya, the water management sector dates back to the National Water Master Plan of 1974 aimed at ensuring potable water availability (at a reasonable distance) to all households by 2000.[8] The task was too large to be completely and directly handled by the government, and as a result the Water Act was introduced before the year 2000. It created a separate Ministry of Water and a state corporation (National Water Conservation and Pipeline Corporation) running water supply systems on a commercial basis.[9] Since 2004, the provision of water and sanitation services has been increasingly transferred or “handed over” to the private sector as a part of the decentralization process.[10]  In rural areas where private-sector providers are few, community self-help groups remain significant despite their marginal presence under the new legal framework of the Water Act 2002 (discussed in depth in Mumma’s article).[11]

On the front of progress, according to the article “Balancing Development and Environmental Conservation and Protection of the Water Resource Base: The ‘Greening’ of Water Laws”, it is indicated that legislation through permits and licenses is the primary instrument of water use regulation and it is now progressively bridging water and environmental concerns.[12] This article acknowledges that there is an increasing trend towards “integrated water resources management”, where water protection provisions are being incorporated within legislation protecting the environment. This has been the case in Kenya, where national reserves or protected areas entail the protection of aquatic ecosystems “in order to secure ecologically sustainable development and use of the water resource” and a stipend is provided for each constituent of the reserve.[13]

Where on the one hand, there is progress in expanding and improving water regulation in Kenya, as well as integrated water resource management and environmental protection, on the other hand, a gradual trend towards decentralization and privatization of service provision has been only resolving the government’s problems in finding capital for service infrastructure, but simultaneously shifting costs of interest payment onto the consumers instead of the government. As well the nature of the legal framework marginalizes customary and traditional (group ownership) norms and rights of use of those living in rural areas who have limited access to state-based systems, and who are unable to meet the requirements for obtaining a permit for water provision (through private land tenure).[14] If consumers have to absorb the costs, services remain distant from some rural areas and permits are difficult to attain, then the rural poor are left in a battle against marginalization and exclusion in the midst of “progressive” reforms.



[1] Hartung, H.; Patschull, C. “Framework for the Inclusion of Rainwater Harvesting in National Water Legislation in Sub-Saharan Africa”. UNEP.
[2] Mumma, Albert. “Kenya’s New Water Law: an Analysis of the Implications of Kenya’s Water Act, 2002, for the Rural Poor”. Chapter 10 in Community-based Water Law and Resource Management Reform in Developing Countries. Ed. B. van Koppen, M. Giordano, J. Butterworth. CAB International: London, 2007, p 163; and ibid Hartung, H.; Patschull, C.
[3] Government of Kenya, Ministry of Water and Irrigation. “The Water Act, 2002 (No.8 of 2002)- The National Water Services Strategy (NWSS) 2007-2015”. May 2007.
[4] Ibid, i.
[5] ibid, ii.
[6] Ibid, ii-iii.
[7] ibid Mumma, p 158.
[8] Ngigi, Ashington; Macharia, Daniel. “Kenya Water Sector Policy Overview Paper”. Enable: Energy for Water, Health, Education. May 2006. ; and ibid Mumma,  p 158.
[9] Ibid Ngigi, p 1; Mumma, p 159.
[10] Ibid, Ngigi p3; Mumma p 160.
[11] ibid Mumma, p 162.
[12] Burki, Stefano. “Balancing Development and Environmental Conservation and Protection of the Water Resource Base: The ‘Greening’ of Water Laws”. FAO Legal Papers Online #65, June 2007. Section 2, p1.
[13] ibid, Section 3.3. quoted from Kenya, Water Act (Cap 732) No 8 of 2002, articles 1 and 13(2).
[14] ibid Mumma, p 163, 164.

Saturday, November 27, 2010

Ecosystem Valuation: A step forward?

Dr. Adhikari provided an exceptionally thorough analysis of key terms and theories on economic valuation, which proved insightful and eye-opening to someone with little economics background.

“How valuable is an ecosystem?” and “to whom?”[1] are core questions to ask from an economics perspective, when thinking of possible ways to increase awareness of decision-makers around the protection of ecosystems. In instances where there are negative externalities resulting from the productive or consumptive activities that inflict involuntary costs on others, the generators of externalities only consider private costs of the economic activity and ignore the social costs they place on others.  The receivers of the service or good (or natural resource in the context of water) incur these social costs in the form of health problems or clean-up costs.

Seeing that water was discussed as having an inefficient and uncompetitive market (no Pareto efficient-meaning it cannot be reallocated to one party without making another party worse off), with a low social surplus, and users prefer to ‘free-ride’ on the provision of this good (tragedy of the commons), it becomes quite difficult to control or to place a value on it.

Various measures were presented to resolve the dilemma including voluntary provisions (i.e tax incentives, reward conservation behaviours), market-oriented measures (i.e cap and trade) and state “command-and-control” mechanisms. Three systems in particular caught my attention:


1) PES (payment for environmental systems)- private payments. This system entails that those downstream pay upstream parties to conserve or preserve the resource.  The idea is that the payment will act as an incentive for those upstream to change their behaviour from exploitation to conservation.

My question concerning its effectiveness is: how can one guarantee that those upstream will in fact change their behaviour or even want to in every case (even with an incentive)? 
Moreover, how equitable is it to make those who are the “victims” in this scenario, pay an additional price for the sake of conserving the resource, while those exploiting the resource get incentives? From an economics perspective this may be seen as a win-win situation, however, moral questions arise when those downstream cannot afford to pay the cost/incentive to change the upstream party's behaviour. How can their dilemma be resolved?


2) Government monitoring. This system requires greater government control by setting legal mechanisms (i.e fines and taxes) to control exploitation of the resource.
Although this system seemed the most convincing to me at the time, Dr. Adhikari soon clarified for me the issues. At times, the cost of compliance can be too high and there is no incentive for governments to implement legal mechanisms. For one reason, there may be political corruption which will falter the system even if it is created, and secondly, governments may fear stifling production by adopting such measures.


3) Public Payments. I found this system to be rather reasonable but certainly not without its caveats. In this system, governments pay entities (such as farmers, NGOs) to conserve particular ecosystems. This has been taking place in countries like Ecuador (where municipal water and electrical utility companies each donate 1% of water revenues for watershed protection), and in Costa Rica among other places. Although this system contributes to the conservation initiatives of certain ecosystems, does it limit or prevent the exploitation of the resource at the level of consumption? 


On this note, water governance is a complex and controversial issue. However, if water can be valuated, then perhaps this will increase its appreciation and conservation. A final question which merits further research on my part is: if water were to be at some point valuated, and a price were to be set, would that be more conducive to changing individuals' or companies’ exploitative behaviour- or would it present an opportunity for private interests to monolopolize the market supply for water, now that a price has been set for it (and a market has been created)? 

* I plan to post a blog over the break regarding water laws in Kenya in preparation for our February trip- stay tuned for that! 

[1] How Much is an Ecosystem Worth? Assessing the Economic Value of Conservation. The World Bank/IUCN/The Nature Conservancy. IBRD/World Bank, Washington DC, 2004.

Saturday, November 13, 2010

A gendered approach to water-sanitation projects.

Much research has proven that water problems and sanitation problems are closely interlinked yet their relationship is most often disregarded. As Dr. Elliot explained, the Cholera outbreak in 19th century England was not linked to water contamination until John Snow plotted a cholera map and realized the concentration of cases was around a particular well in the city. Similarly today, it is not well acknowledged that approximately 10% of the global health burden is affected by water.*

Solutions provided at the macro level may not be very successful due to the specificity and variety of perceptions on sanitation at a micro-level such as attitudes, practices and risk perception, the psychosocial impacts of other problems, the levels of social cohesion, and most importantly gender roles.  
If community members are not willing to use latrines, then why bother build them?

I would like to, however, dedicate this blog to highlight the gendered face of water-health problems. There is more relevance to addressing gender equity in water-related management than is generally discussed. Although there was a section devoted to exploring women’s role in Safe Water as the Key to Global Health (2008)- an effort which is commended- it was too brief.* This area of research warrants further investigation. Women bear the burden of a majority of household chores that necessitate water use (cooking, cleaning, washing laundry, walking for miles to fill up containers). They also carry the heavier burden of tending to their ill children and family members who get infected with diseases that are waterborne. Despite their customary higher contact with water, they tend to be marginalized in decision-making around improving water and health standards.  As Dr. Wallace explained, asking the men within a community for their solutions yields a completely different set of answers than that of women’s. Yet within communities built on patriarchal norms, it is expected that the men's decisions be considered.

This is why encouraging greater gender engagement in addressing water problems and explaining to women within a community how their burden can be lessened as a result, will most likely foster greater support for water and sanitation projects.

My impression is that due to the taboos around the subject of bodily wastes, sanitation has been sidelined, both as a topic of conversation and an investment priority. "In Deep Democracy: Urban Governmentality and the Horizon of Politics", Arjun Appadurai explores the work of the Alliance, an NGO based in Mumbai which allows slum dwellers to work together to improve their standards of living. One example that caught my attention was celebrating "toilet festivals" (32).** The main idea is to redeem humiliation through a politics of recognition. Celebrating a toilet will rid it of the stigma associated with it. Initiatives like "toilet festivals" and encouraging increased female participation, mothers and young girls, can be one way to increase the success of water-sanitation projects and to achieve a sustainable community-based solution. 
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
* Corinne J. Schuster-Wallace, Velma I. Grover, Zafar Adeel, Ulisses Confalonieri, Susan Elliott , “Safe Water as the Key to Global Health” (2008), pp.10
** Arjun Appadurai, "Deep Democracy: Urban Governmentality and the Horizon of Politics". Public Culture. 14, 1 (2002), pp 21-47.
*** Brodie Morgan Ramin and Anthony J. McMichael, "Climate Change and Health in Sub-Saharan Africa: A Case-Based Perspective", EcoHealth 6 (2009), pp 52–57. 
I very much enjoyed the case-specific approach used in this article selected by Dr. Wallace and Dr. Elliot for their presentation. The use of the affected individuals’ names as titles for the case studies permits focusing importance on the human suffering caused by changing environmental conditions, and water was an indirect- sometimes even direct- factor, whether due to a flood, dehydration, drought, mal-nourishment etc. It is worth noting that most of the cases were reported by women.